Once you decide there just are five income groups no matter their income, the third quintile might average $20,000 or $200,000 per year, might be able to afford rent in Oakland or not, but as long as they are in the middle, shazam, you can talk about the “middle class.” This is one of the many reasons that sociologists should be driven into the sea.
Many of our terms for political positions are equally debased and so lack descriptive power. People use them anyway. Their seeming functionality depends on the fact that the master pairing, left vs right, is—à la the quintile—a relative formulation. So as long as they are left of something, you can cheerfully refer to Hillary voters as the left and Bernie voters as the far left, ignoring the fact that for a century—a century including what would be called “the old left” and “the new left,” the left of the Black Panthers and Stonewall—the term persistently referred to the people who, among other things, did not vote for the mainstream parties and wanted to bring capitalism to an end. Now you are a bomb-hurling maniac for suggesting a trivial tax increase. The left used to feature actual bomb-hurling maniacs, and anyone who doesn’t miss those days is off my Hanukkah list.
This collapse of terminological efficacy is crucial context for the contemporary conflicts that pit the left against the left, since “the left” can now mean pretty much anything. (Henceforth, please treat all appearances of the word as swathed in scare quotes.) These struggles have been particularly vitriolic in the UK of late. Here I do not mean the vindictive bullshit of groups that only pretend to progressive politics while espousing deeply reactionary politics, like the hydra-headed TERF bigots. Rather I refer to actual left-on-left turmoil such as the debate over Brexit. In an outcome marking the declining power of the political spectrum to explain things, the vote did not fall easily along party lines, with about two-fifths of Tories voting Remain, more than one-third of Labor voting Leave. Party discipline that ain’t.
The split on the left was brutal. The Leave vote was championed by open xenophobes, cognate to the Build a Wall crowd in the USA. This made it easy to suggest that any Leave voter was of that ilk. The anti-immigration policies implied by leaving the EU only added to this. Consequently, “Lexit” voters (those claiming a left rationale for exit) were treated by other leftists as themselves obviously racist and xenophobic, regardless of their claims. Their claims were these: that the European Union is an incomparable engine of soft domination able to impose the will of its masters with shocking ease, its power increasing year by year—and it is also, for related reasons, doomed to fail, hence the UK should get out while the getting is merely terrible. But you’re racists, was the rebuttal. But you’re tools of technocrats in Berlin and Brussels, shot back les Lexiteers. I have seen a lot of sectarian splits in my life, and this time I just made emoji prayer hands that I lived in another country.
The ceaseless slippage to which the left has exposed itself has made it more prone than ever to be drawn into traps such as these, though really it is nothing new; being drawn into siding with warring states in the First World War was arguably the worst debacle for the European left in the twentieth century. Siding with bourgeois states is not the left’s fate but its fatal leap. There is no evident solution aside from abandoning the left-right spectrum altogether. It may be that, in the present, a more powerful and persuasive orientation is centers and peripheries. One thing about the eurozone: it has proved to be an astonishing technology for sucking value into its core, meaning Germany, from its far reaches, meaning almost everywhere else. This arrangement of forces is troublingly similar to the structure of England, where the international financial power of the City has allowed London to be in essence the sole beneficiary of any national profits, while the outlands moulder. Unsurprisingly, this is reflected dramatically in the Brexit vote: London was the only region in England to go Remain.
This all proposes a political project for the left, if that term is to preserve any meaning. It is certainly not to woo or even coddle the xenophobes into a voting alliance. Rather it is to reaffirm its commitment to absolute war on the economic regime that moves money and livelihoods from peripheral counties to the capital, peripheral nations to the core. This will not be the left of Leave or Remain, will not be the left of a fictional middle class, and will not be the left of the master parties. It will be the left of unmaking the UK and the EU as containers of political and economic power premised on the immiseration of some for the wealth of others, in obvious and in hidden ways. If the mustachioed monopoly men won’t go easily, it may include bomb-hurling maniacs.
Hmm, looks like you don’t have MetaMask activated!
If you know what MetaMask is and have it installed, activate MetaMask and refresh:
If that doesn’t make sense to you, click here:
The MetaMask window should have popped up and asked if you want Popula to have access to your MetaMask. Click the ‘CONFIRM’ button.
Don’t see the MetaMask window? Click here to request it again:
You have an old version of the MetaMask extension installed. Before we can continue, you must install the latest version.
- Uninstall (don’t just disable) the existing extension from your browser.
- Restart your browser.
- Go to metamask.io and re-install the extension.
- Come back here and try again!
We know this step is inconvenient, but it’s necessary to make sure this all goes smoothly!
Your MetaMask extension is running, but for privacy purposes you have to allow us to connect to your MetaMask wallet.
You need to connect to the Main Net before you can actually tip. Click on your MetaMask icon so the window pops up, then select ‘Main Ethereum Network’ from the dropdown.
How much do you want to tip?
You can adjust either amount to see how much ETH or USD you’ll be sending.
You can adjust the tip amount in the MetaMask popup window before confirming the transaction.
Popula’s authors contribute 5% of their tips to Popula to help with the overhead of running the tipping system.
Author participation in the Popula tipping system is optional; if an author declines to participate in the tipping system, your tip will be refunded to you in full within 60 days.
Your MetaMask window has popped up now, and you need to confirm the transaction.
Hit that ‘CONFIRM’ button to make it happen!
Did you reject the transaction by accident? Want to adjust your tip amount? Click here:
Maybe you’re not quite comfortable with this yet?
That transaction didn’t go through for some reason.
Try clicking on the MetaMask button in your browser bar (looks like this: ) and see if you have any transactions listed at the bottom of the popup. If you don’t see the tip you just tried to leave, then try again:
Or just want to ask us about it? We’ look into it personally for you.
Thank you so much for your tip, and for your direct support of journalism. The author will appreciate it a lot, and so do all of us at Popula.
Want a receipt?
To see your transaction logged in MetaMask, click the MetaMask button in your browser toolbar—this one: —and your transaction will be listed in the popup.
You can also track the transaction on the Etherscan website. It usually takes under a minute to process, and you’ll get a notification from MetaMask when it’s done.Track on Etherscan
If you have any questions at all, please let us know!
All set?Home to Popula, please!
We know this cryptocurrency stuff is new and weird. We’re here to help you understand. Ask us firstname.lastname@example.org
ETH is Ether, a popular cryptocurrency generated on the Ethereum blockchain.
You’ll need some Ethereum cryptocurrency (ETH) in a MetaMask wallet in order to tip an author. Currently it’s not possible to tip in other cryptocurrencies, or in dollars or other fiat currencies.
For a comprehensive FAQ to help get you started, please visit our help page, “How to Tip Your Favorite Authors with Cryptocurrency on Popula!”
If you have any questions at all, please let us know!